Gluten-Free Thumbprint Cookies: Classic Jam + 3 Wild Fillings You Need Don’t Need to Try!
These buttery, rich, gluten-free thumbprint cookies are delicious no matter what jam you use—but I decided to get a little wild in the kitchen…
I tested a few unexpected fillings, and here's what happened:
Peanut Butter (use regular, not natural):Deliciously nutty with the cookie, but bakes up a little weird-looking. Still worth it.
Peanut Butter & Jelly:Tastes like I need more filling, but I couldn’t fit enough jelly in the cookie to really shine. Better with just jam.
Fluffernutter (PB + Marshmallow):Sounds like a dream, right? It almost works… but I wanted way more filling than fits in a thumbprint. Good in theory, better in a sandwich.
Classic jam still wins—but experimenting was too fun not to share!
Would you try any of these? I included the recipe link for you below. Like and follow for all gluten-free bakes.
https://www.chillybakesglutenfree.com/blog/thumbprint-cookies-classic-jam--3-wild-fillings-you-probably-dont-need-to-try/
#over50women #GlutenFreeBaking #ThumbprintCookies #GlutenFreeCookies #CookieExperiment #PeanutButterLovers #Fluffernutter #BakingFailsAndWins #CreativeBaking #EasyBakingIdeas #GlutenFreeDesserts #glutenfreelife #shorts #thumbprints